Min:24 °C Max:32 °C
» Weather Details
November 23, 2009 Monday

ST Breaking News | Blogs | ST's Home Ground
Judith Tan
News Correspondent
Fractured but not shaken
July 06, 2009 Monday, 11:57 AM
Judith Tan insists it is ok for her to drive despite fracturing her left ankle.

THREE weeks ago I fractured my left ankle.

I was exercising on the trampoline when I landed with all of my weight on my left foot in such a way that my ankle rolled outwards.

I heard a ‘kraak’ sound as I went down but as it at first seemed like a bad sprain, I thought no more about the sound.

Besides, after about 20 minutes of icing it down, I tried placing my weight on the ankle joint and discovered that I was able to move around with only a little discomfort. But later, walking became much more difficult.

It was only after a visit to an emergency department the next day that an x-ray confirmed a nasty crack in my outer ankle bone (with the interesting name of lateral malleolus).

The doctors placed my leg in a cast that runs from my toes to just below my knee.

The result: I am not allowed to place any pressure on my left leg and need crutches to move about.

Never one to be sedentary, I decided I could still carry on with my daily life – much to the horror of an overly-concerned mother.

Since then, I have had many heated debates with her about my ability, or lack of ability to do so, particularly when it comes to driving my car.

I would understand her concern if I were still driving my previous car - a manual transmission, which would require me to use my left foot on the clutch. But as I now drive an automatic car, I argue that my left foot is redundant.

So here I sit - immobilised.

I’ve finished reading the novels I planned to catch up on and caught up with the TV series which I missed by working late shifts – thanks to late press releases on the Influenza A (H1N1) cases.

I’ve tried reasoning with and even begging my mother to let me drive but the answer is still “no”. Determined to win the argument, I went online to check Google for the legalities of driving with a cast on your leg.

I found it was certainly not alright to drive with a leg cast in Britain and in some parts of the United States but I could find nothing relating to the traffic laws here. The only thing to do – ask the Singapore Police.

Its spokesman, ASP Stanley Norbert, told me that as long as the driver is able to manage the vehicle competently, cast notwithstanding, it is not illegal to drive. But he did caution that when it comes to insurance coverage, it may be a totally different story.

Not to be defeated, I emailed several insurers on the issue – a few replied. Some said they needed time to check their policy, others simply ignored the email.

But Mr Pui Phusangmook, the Senior Vice-President and General Manager for NTUC Income’s General Insurance Division replied.

He said: “For the given scenario of a policyholder driving with the left foot in a cast, there would be no change in our motor insurance coverage if the Traffic Police permits this, and if the driver can manage the vehicle competently.”
 
Armed with that information – and the echo of my friends' constant harping for me to just get on with my life, I am ready to take on the roads – and yes, my mother as well.



Tags: , , , ,

 
Total comments: 7
Sanook Thai
July 07, 2009 Tuesday

Error will slip through a crack, while truth will stick in the doorway said H.W. Shaw.
Take note of this advice and pray that nothing goes wrong.
Cheers!

comment 5789 | Offensive? Report this comment
Rahul Bhade
July 07, 2009 Tuesday

Hi Judith,

I've just recovered for an ankle fracture too,that of the "medial mallelous",if the lingo makes any sense...I was out of action for 3 months,and very seriously envied people who were "walking" or doing just about anything without crutches or a wheelchair...its good to be back on the feet again,and its really commendable about your intention to drive and the support you are receiving...best of luck,and you'll be back to normal as well..so cheers!

comment 5786 | Offensive? Report this comment
Judith Tan
July 07, 2009 Tuesday

Thank you EnglishPolice. The relevant people had been notified and changes made.

comment 5782 | Offensive? Report this comment
englishpolice
July 07, 2009 Tuesday

hi Judith, glad your'e feeling better. I just had to point out that the English in this essay sucks! There are several spelling errors, and inconsistent tenses abound. What happened? Are the editors/copywriters/proofreaders at ST all messed up?

comment 5776 | Offensive? Report this comment
evozero
July 07, 2009 Tuesday

You may also want to look at the SMA Fitness to Drive guidelines
http://www.sma.org.sg/references/

comment 5775 | Offensive? Report this comment

Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply:

(1) Stay on topic;
(2) No abuse, please;
(3) No personal attacks;
(4) No curse words;
(5) Don't SCREAM in ALL CAPS!

To encourage a meaningful and pleasant dialogue, comments may be deleted. We look forward to your participation!

Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement | Terms & Conditions