The Straits Times Web
Min:24 °C Max:30 °C
» Weather Details
February 09, 2010 Tuesday

ST Breaking News | Blogs | Joanne's Digerati Diaries, ST's Home Ground
Joanne Lee
Straits Times Online Editor
Why I hung up my pointe shoes
July 02, 2009 Thursday, 04:02 PM
Joanne Lee mulls over today's Life! cover story on the lack of local dancers.

WHEN I read my Life! colleague Tara Tan's cover story today - Where have all the dancers gone? - I couldn't help feel a bittersweet twinge in my balletomane's heart.

You see, my passion when I was younger was ballet. I started the good-toes-bad-toes regime when I was four, and only stopped proper training when I went off to university when I was 18.

So obsessed was I that, at age 10, I wrote off to an English school and got in based on my Royal Academy of Dancing results, presenting my shocked parents with a fait accompli. (Of course, I wasn't allowed to go.)

Still, from four till 18, I trained at least thrice weekly at the Singapore Ballet Academy under local ballet doyen Goh Soo Khim, won several scholarships to train abroad and danced as a scholar with the Singapore Dance Theatre (SDT) from the days of its inception.

Why, do you ask, didn't I pursue my passion?

Well, I suppose I was a pragmatic Singaporean. My shrewd father planted thoughts in my head such as: "What if you get injured? You'll have no 'O' Levels to fall back on. And if you end up as a ballet teacher, will you be happy with the income level and will you be able to enjoy the quality of your life?" Totally logical. Sigh.

To his credit, he only required me to finish my 'O' Levels, and let me decide whether to do my 'A' Levels. Having being offered a position in the government's junior college Humanities Programme, and later getting a place in a top UK university, I knew I would break my father's heart if I chose pirouettes over political science.

So I hung up the toe shoes.

My last pair. Circa 1993
ST Photo: Joanne Lee

Back to why local dancers don't return though. The reason is simple: Artistes are simply not respected as they are in other countries for their talent and years of sacrifice.

It's akin to the argument about why Singapore sports talents choose not to pursue their particular passion - because the input greatly outweighs the output. True, the payout of true passion is never weighed out in gold, but in this materialistic world, unless you're a Tiger Woods or a Michael Phelps (in ballet terms: a Sylvie Guillem or a Darcey Bussell), it's hard to support oneself - and even a family - on passion alone.

What about the renaissance artists then? One might argue. How would we have had a Michelangelo or a Da Vinci if they paid more heed to their empty stomachs than sculpting or painting? Well, that argument holds no water, because in those days, artists were treasured and taken care of by the likes of the rich Medici families and various European courts.

So that is the nub of it. Who is going to step up to support our local artistes? As far as I know with the Singapore Dance Theatre back in the days, it had enough corporate sponsorship to cover its costs, but not enough to pay its dancers salaries on par with foreign companies. (Things could well be different now, I shan't assume.)

Also, reality check: Singapore is a little red dot.

Foreign companies simply have more talent to pit oneself against, and they have the choreographic breadth and the artistic scope for dancers to challenge and bolster their range.

Take Kuik Swee Boon - whom Tara featured in Life! today. He started his ballet training with us when I was about 15. (Men, you see, can start training much later in life unlike girls who need to start at four.)

Artistic Director of
T.H.E. Dance Company now.
ST file photo

After I'd left Singapore's shores to pursue an academic education, Swee Boon went on to nurture his exceptional talent and ended up as the SDT's danseur noble - the male equivalent of a ballerina.

Every time I watched him improve from performance to performance, I'd cry inside - because that could have been me. Indeed, when the SDT moved to its then-new premises at Fort Canning, he was my partner at the opening ceremony.

I'm much fatter now, obviously.
ST file photo

Swee Boon left Singapore and the SDT in 2002 to join Spain's Compania Nacional de Danza as a principal dancer - a great feat for a locally-trained dancer - in all probability for all the reasons I outlined above.

But he came back.

In 2007, he decided to return after five years "to pass on the knowledge" he had gleaned and is now artistic director of his own company T.H.E. Dance Company.

Hopefully more dancers like him will follow their dreams but bring those dreams home again one day. And, even more importantly, hopefully more corporates and the-man-in-the-audience will treasure our home-trained dancers as national talents that require more financial support if they stay in Singapore.

Maybe, just maybe, had that been the case back when I had to make those hard decisions, I would have chosen differently and not be sitting here at the computer now on my cellulite-ridden posterior.

Why do you think our dancers don't return? Leave your comments here.



Tags: , , ,

 
Total comments: 46
Singapore Girl Next Door
July 25, 2009 Saturday

http://theonlinecitizen.com/2009/07/ntu-student-protests-against-censorship-in-graduation-speech/

This says it all. Listen carefully on the last words where the speaker emphasized the role of artists in society.

comment 6176 | Offensive? Report this comment
foreignercitizen
July 22, 2009 Wednesday

Can anyone else play here too?

So,Chips Goodyear is not taking up the position of CEO of Temasek.
We can wonder what really happened behind those closed doors.

Picture this: tense boardroom arguments.
Chips detailing his plan. After weeks of late night wranglings, he stands in front of the Temasek Board with his ideas, his charts and his strategies.
HC shakes her head. No can do, she is heard to mumour, under her breath.
Dhanablan, after conferring with MM on the telephone,too, shakes his head. No can do, too, he seems to say.
Temperature in the boardoom reaches fever pitch.

Chips pounds his fists to get his point across. He raises his voice.
HC bursts into tears and says," I am going to tell the PM and MM about you."
Chips says. "Okay,I have had enough. You all win, I am going."

Anyone else has other ideas of how it all came about?



comment 6115 | Offensive? Report this comment
amanstbasher
July 20, 2009 Monday

It may be off-topic, but its important to be read. And where better than the Online Ed's own blog.
------------------------------

This is the question the Sraits Times was afraid to ask the Ministry of Health. (Because the ST NEVER asks the government any questions, in any case)

Well, I asked the question by email. And this is the prompt reply received from a Yusnita Helmi from the Ministry of Health.

My question: WHY WILL SINGAPOREANS HAVE TO PAY FOR THE VACCINE WHEN COUNTRIES LIKE AUSTRALIA AND THE UK ARE GOING TO PROVIDE IT FREE FOR THEIR PEOPLE?

The answer in full...today 20/7/09
"We refer to your email below and would like to share with you that the H1N1 vaccine, when available, will be offered on a voluntary basis.

Those who wish to be vaccinated, after considering their risk profile and understanding the possible side effects of any vaccination, will have to pay for it.
This is similar to existing arrangements for other forms of vaccination. Patients who have difficulties paying will be given the necessary assistance as per current practice.

We would like to share that we are still evaluating submissions from tenderers from our recent tender exercise to supply a vaccine, and we will secure enough vaccine for our people. Our key considerations will be safety and efficacy and these will be known only after clinical trials have been completed. The details will be released as soon as we are ready.

The Ministry will like to advise Singaporeans to still maintain a high standard of hygiene and exercising social responsibility and distancing in the meantime, to prevent contracting of the virus.

Wishing you and your family good health always."

SO NOW YOU KNOW!!
Don't everyone rush to thank me. As always, its a pleasure .

comment 6095 | Offensive? Report this comment
samannah
July 17, 2009 Friday

FYI, amanstbasher & dorkedog (and who knows what other handles ...., but same message) are the same blogger. Read "A germaphobe's nightmare" last few entries.

comment 6050 | Offensive? Report this comment
dorkedog
July 17, 2009 Friday

Hello Joanne. The reason why I chose to write you, is because you blogged about the flu thingy.
But as I anticipated, its a cop-out.
I DID WRITE YOU IN YOUR BLOG.."A germophobe's nightmare"..but you chose not to bother to answer.
Will the ST ever ask the government any questions?
How about asking THE big boss upstairs and he could put it to the Health Minister. He must have a direct line to him.
After all, its a very important issue and concerns every Singaporean. As a national paper, you lot should be asking these questions ahead of us asking. This papers editor should have picked this up and give it to some hack to follow through.
But then, we get what we get,dont we?
Why then do you think questions and views have to appear in Asiaone Forum instead?

You suggest..write in. But will you publish it?
Or pray, short of space in the paper..er..again?

comment 6040 | Offensive? Report this comment

Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply:

(1) Stay on topic;
(2) No abuse, please;
(3) No personal attacks;
(4) No curse words;
(5) Don't SCREAM in ALL CAPS!

To encourage a meaningful and pleasant dialogue, comments may be deleted. We look forward to your participation!

Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement | Terms & Conditions