Min:24 °C Max:32 °C
» Weather Details
November 23, 2009 Monday

ST Breaking News | Blogs | From Around The World
Elizabeth Looi
Malaysia Correspondent
Democracy has its limits
March 20, 2009 Friday, 03:00 PM
Elizabeth Looi discusses the first use of cyber law in Malaysia.

IN KUALA LUMPUR

EIGHT people have been arrested so far but only one has pleaded guilty.

All of them were hauled to court last week for condemning the Perak ruler, Sultan Azlan Shah, online. They were charged under a cyber law for irresponsible and offensive comments.

They were alleged to have posted insulting comments on the Sultan's website. They apparently blamed the Sultan for not making a wise decision when tackling the political situation in Perak.

Sultan Azlan Shah had asked Pakatan Rakyat to back down and let Barisan Nasional take over the silver state instead of dissolving the state assembly and allowing fresh polls.

Many people were unhappy with his decision but some went a little too far when they ALLEGEDLY hurled insults at the monarch ON THE WEBSITE.

This is the first time ever for anyone to be charged under the cyber law, the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998. But the charge was quite an awakening for Malaysians.

It shocked some very prominent bloggers. They didn't think that the government would have gone after ordinary Malaysians. They thought the cyber cops were only investigating them all this while.
Some people felt the eight deserved to be charged and thrown behind bars for not respecting the Sultan. They said this should be a lesson for online users to be careful with what they write on public forums.

A reader known only as Truth Seeking Citizen, who commented on the popular Rocky's Bru blog, called for Malaysians to wake up and read blogs with a pinch of salt.

"Use your wisdom to make your own decision. Blind support or following at your own peril! We need a better Malaysia, the blogsphere has in recent months been adulterated with lies and false allegations without any substantive evidence. It is also unfortunate that many who seek to reform, better governance, accountability and integrity has fallen into the trap of this cult of blind support," the reader said.

But of course, there are some who disagreed with the arrest and slammed the government for setting a precedent for online censorship.

Non-governmental organisations Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ) and the Writers Alliance for Media Independence (WAMI) were worried that it could "be the start of a clampdown on online expression and the erosion of the right to discuss the role of the Malaysian royal families".

"It goes against Malaysia's commitment of no internet censorship legislated in section 3(3) of CMA and in the Multimedia Bill of Guarantees.

"The violation of the promise is a sign that the government, at the brink of the impending change in prime minister-ship, is getting more authoritarian," said Wami chairperson Wong Chin Huat and CIJ executive director V. Gayanthry in a statement.

They also took it as a move to further silence and spread fear among the public.

There are also some blog readers who suggested that all bloggers to unite and collect funds to help out with the legal fees for the seven of them who claimed trial.

But at the end of the day, I think it is safe to say that no one should abuse freedom of speech.

As an anonymous blog reader says: "Democracy has its limits. So does freedom. It does not mean that democracy allows one to fornicate in public or to commit suicide. Neither does it give one the right to destroy careers of others.

"In brief, do things reasonably and logically. Don't expect dignitaries to take things sitting down. When a tiger is pushed to the wall, it will naturally pounce back."



Tags: ,

 
Total comments: 7
sizzlestick
March 24, 2009 Tuesday

comment 3345 Malaysian
... a Singapore PR, domiciled in said country since seven, earn a living in Singapore Economy, appreciate "the PAP is doing a really good job taking care of the country and the people". If Singapore so nice, why this complaining about Malaysia... just become a Singapore Citizen. When instead you just love and laud Singapore and like "many Singaporeans usually have negative impressions when talked about Malaysia'.

comment 3391 | Offensive? Report this comment
Malaysian
March 23, 2009 Monday

I am a Malaysian with Singapore PR.
I have lived here since I was seven and have half of my family who are citizens here and also across the border in Malaysia.
As a citizen holding a Malaysia passport, I have to say that I am deeply disappointed with the way things are being handled in Malaysia. I am sure many Singaporeans usually have negative impressions when talked about Malaysia, but to be fair to all, I hope you all know that even we Malaysians are being fed up with our so called 'Democratic Government'. That is why you see the opposition scoring record votes recently. The majority of Malaysians, especially the younger generations, who had the priviledge of education both locally and in foreign countries, are waking up and not following blindly like our parents had done. We demand equal rights among all citizens regardless of gender, race and religion. We would also like to see improved relations with neighbouring countries such as Singapore, Indonesia and Thailand. I have to admit that the long years in control have made our Government arrogant, having them rest on their laurels and probably imagining that things could go on in their favour for a long long time still. Such is not the case. Unfortunately, our attempts to voice out over such inequalities have seen people being arrest as the above matter, including using the ISA. But looking at the bright side, this is a severe over reaction, and seriously if the Government have nothing to hide why resort to such measures ? All these stories have received a lot of public coverage. At least with more people against these movements, the more power we have to change our Government and future. The people have forgotten that the Government ARE servents of the people, not the other way round. To be honest, in Singapore the same thing might be happening with the PAP in full control. But one thing is for sure, at least the PAP is doing a really good job taking care of the country and the people. Some people may disagree but you only have to visit other countries in South Asia to realise the stark differences in the quality of life. What we need in Malaysia is a revolution. But right now it is going to take time as we would never resort to violence and bloodshed, and if this is what is needed for a peaceful change, we will wait patiently for it, doing what we can in between.

comment 3345 | Offensive? Report this comment
Jurgen
March 23, 2009 Monday

The title of the story "democracy has its limits" is strange. Democracy doesn't have limits, it has rules.
Also as Brian points out, the subject of the arrests is NOT democracy but about power, in this case of UMNO. On the other hand, the topic is worth pondering by any citizen of any country. I believe in basically any country those on power tend to use remarkable means to stay there.

comment 3344 | Offensive? Report this comment
Brien
March 22, 2009 Sunday

This the death of democracy and freedom. This is dictatorship. People deserve the government that they tolerate.

comment 3339 | Offensive? Report this comment
sharlynrj
March 20, 2009 Friday

I suppose its easier to talk about another persons country than your own , because you can be more fothcoming and flippant.
I just wonder if Elizabeth Looi knows what democracy is, rather than state that it has its limits.


comment 3301 | Offensive? Report this comment

Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply:

(1) Stay on topic;
(2) No abuse, please;
(3) No personal attacks;
(4) No curse words;
(5) Don't SCREAM in ALL CAPS!

To encourage a meaningful and pleasant dialogue, comments may be deleted. We look forward to your participation!

Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement | Terms & Conditions