Min:24 °C Max:32 °C
» Weather Details
November 23, 2009 Monday

ST Breaking News | Blogs | From Around The World
Joanne Lee
Straits Times Online Editor
Was Rihanna semi-responsible?
March 13, 2009 Friday, 06:08 PM
Joanne Lee looks at her own experience with dating abuse.

I ONCE dated a guy who hit me.

Not in the full-on Chris-Brown-biting-Rihanna's-ears kind of way, but we'd argue and he'd get so worked up, he'd punch the wall and shove me around a little. (It'd usually be a one-off punch because he was inherently a decent guy who knew it was wrong to hit anyone.)

Rihanna post-abuse.
PHOTO: Reuters

Domestic/dating abuse has obviously blown up in the news since the R&B stars' violent episode last month came to light and Chris Brown was charged in court this week. Oprah Winfrey dedicated her show to the two of them and, while sending her love to the two, also said: "If a man hits you once, he will hit you again."

Happier times.
PHOTO: AP

Initially, the condemnation all over the Internet and media was against Chris Brown. A man raising his hand against the weaker sex is just something absolutely socially unacceptable.

But a second strain of judgement has surfaced, turning against Rihanna, saying: Yes, she might be a victim but she also probably provoked Chris Brown to violence.

Domestic abuse social workers would absolutely dismiss this secondary reaction, and I don't purport to know the natures of Chris Brown or Rihanna at all, but I can understand why some people would think the victim is not entirely blameless.

You see, my ex was Chris Brown's age, 19 (give or take) at the time. We were young, we had tempers and we had not the maturity to control those tempers. When he hit me those few times, I'll freely admit, I had a part to play in the outcome.

When I was younger, I was argumentative and it didn't help that I had a way with words - twisting words, to be precise. If he got frustrated and ended up hitting out at animate (me) or inanimate objects (mirrors), I honestly can't say it was entirely his fault.

Was this the case in Rihanna's situation? I don't know. Is it the case in all domestic abuse situations? Absolutely not. Some men just cannot control their violence and there is nothing to be done for it except for the woman to leave the monster to protect themselves and, God forbid, their children.

But what I do know, is that in my case, I contributed to his anger - which is why I forgave him time and time again (not that there were many times) and did not leave him. When we broke up in the end, it was for entirely different reasons.

As far as I know, he's now happily married, a father and doing well in his career. As for me, I think I've learned to bridle my tongue and be a more give-and-take kind of partner. (And I stress, give-and-take. Not give-and-give.)

So my humble advice to anyone out there facing mild cases of domestic/dating abuse is this: If you can help the situation by changing yourself, perhaps that's something to try if you truly love the guy.

Operative word: MILD.

If he's saying "I'm going to kill you", arm-locking you and biting your ears, no matter how much you look within yourself to try to improve your relationship, I really doubt your man is going to grow out of his temper tantrums.

Rihanna, leave the dude already.

Do you think Rihanna should leave Chris Brown? Do you even think it matters? Leave your comments here.

Update @ Monday March 16th: Read Joanne's response to the comments on this entry here: Getting the best reply of all.



Tags: , ,

 
Total comments: 82
sharlynrj
March 27, 2009 Friday

Thank you... TLC.
Now I understand.
The man once said..we get the newspaper we deserve.
I ask..why?
His reply..was...because...er..just..because...we deserve no better.
Very often I too believe that this newspaper/blog writes for its own ego.
The reader is of no value, until we stop buying the paper or the advertisers stop advertising.
But then pigs will fly as there is no choice.
Maybe if and when "the new media" is available, it will not be patronising to its readers.
We live in hope.



comment 3485 | Offensive? Report this comment
TLC
March 27, 2009 Friday

sharlynrj, far too often this publication forget who's the real audience.

i often speak to new journalists who say they write for Singapore, for the MPs, for the Singapore PM. they want to play a role in the success of our country and our government.

i'm not sure if they were directing an insult to MPs or the PM, but you and i will agree that the quality of the publication is only for those who are not discerning.

they had instead done a great disservice to our nation by understating the intelligence of the real audience,

,,,none other than the Singaporean masses.

as eloquently stated by one American who directed a question to the President - there is no difference between a free society and an educated society.

to keep the public well-informed and educated about the issues of our country is a both a privelege and a responsibility bestowed to the media.

instead, we see shinanigans.

if this publication had seen drop in readership, it is only because their readers have spoken.

comment 3475 | Offensive? Report this comment
sharlynrj
March 27, 2009 Friday

Hear hear, TLC..but...can you please explain to simple-minded me what you mean by saying..."As for Joanne, she threw fuel in a fire. I hope she is reminded, and this is a lesson she should hold on, as a journalist, she is judged by her readers."

comment 3453 | Offensive? Report this comment
TLC
March 27, 2009 Friday

Behave or be beaten.

It's ridiculous how some Singaporeans audaciously suggest that women should know their place even in situations such as domestic violence, further insinuating that women even in today's society have no options but to merely follow those that society had set for them. And in cases of abuse, behave or be beaten.

While physical violence is being condemned, women are blindly blamed anyway, insisting that women's role in maintaining a docile behaviour takes precedent than the need for her partner to act like a human being.

I'm deeply saddened but grossly disgusted first by the lack of intelligence of some readers.

As for Joanne, she threw fuel in a fire. I hope she is reminded, and this is a lesson she should hold on, as a journalist, she is judged by her readers.

comment 3451 | Offensive? Report this comment
pimpmaster
March 26, 2009 Thursday

To the latest set of readers -

So let's beat women, claim physical abuse is wrong, but put the blame on women anyway?

Given that peaceful and better methods of resolving a conflict are available to us, as human beings, it's unbelievable there are Singaporeans, despite their claims of civility, have a myopic view that women only have two choices - behave or beaten....

....and as for those who are passionate about this issue and disagree that women "had it coming", they are the ones now accused of being "verbally abusive" acting without civility.

BEHAVE or be BEATEN.

Only in Singapore, ladies and gentlemen.

comment 3445 | Offensive? Report this comment

Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply:

(1) Stay on topic;
(2) No abuse, please;
(3) No personal attacks;
(4) No curse words;
(5) Don't SCREAM in ALL CAPS!

To encourage a meaningful and pleasant dialogue, comments may be deleted. We look forward to your participation!

Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement | Terms & Conditions