Min:24 °C Max:32 °C
» Weather Details
November 23, 2009 Monday

ST Breaking News | Blogs | ST's Home Ground
Wong Mei Ling
Journalist, Foreign Desk
Message in a city
February 05, 2009 Thursday, 02:45 PM
Wong Mei Ling wonders what message Singapore sends out as a city.

PAUL Graham, a famous venture capitalist-cum-author said: "In a hundred subtle ways, the city sends you a message".

In Cambridge, home to some of the world's most brilliant intellectuals, the message is: You should be smarter. 

In London, the cornerstone of English royal history, the indelible message is: One should be more aristocratic.

In New York, the financial heartbeat of the United States, the message, loud and clear, is: You should be richer. 

And in Silicon Valley, the Zion of our new electronic world, the clear signal is: You should be more powerful.

Paul Graham doesn't mention other major Asian cities, but it got me thinking: What message does Singapore send out to you - as a Singaporean, an expat or a tourist?

When asked this question, a Swiss friend of mine working in the island state said Singapore's message is: "One should try to be liberal but still conservative at the same time". And of course, one should also own that car, condo, credit cards and country club memberships.

The message I got coming back after more than two years overseas is: "One should be in a hurry". One must be quick or lose out, be it queuing for the famous Katong laksa or getting married and having children.

Everyone seemed to walk so fast and trample on my toes to get on the bus (even though no one else was boarded and plenty of seats were available). 

But even more shocking for me when I came home was to find many of my peers (in their late twenties) married and expecting their first kid. When catching up with relatives, their first question was not how was your experience overseas, but when are you getting married? How bizarre!

Yet another message I picked up was: "One should work harder". Nothing wrong with that, but the hard work should continue even if one is exhausted and just about ready to drop. One must still work harder, or at least look like it. Huh?

While I was happily extending my student life by two years, my friends had been doing 12 hour days (and more) and working into their weekends too. They looked much older, they had dark patches under their eyes and some looked like they hadn't stepped out into the sun for a decade.

No wonder beauty parlours and spa businesses have been sprouting like wild flowers.

Even before the financial crisis, I noticed few happy faces on the train in the morning rush hour. Indeed, there are fewer happy faces in the after-office peak hour. People either seem to sleep, space out or lose themselves in computer games on their mobiles or handheld game consoles. They don't even look like they are looking forward to going home.

In a hundred subtle ways the message a city sends to an external observer lives in the subconsciousness of its inhabitants. Surely there is more to the message Singapore gives than this? 

And don't mistake this to be a question of what people think of you based on the clothes you wear or the brand of your bag. This message is embedded in one's facial expression and body language. 

What message does this city send to you? And more importantly, what message do you want to send to the city?

I would like to see more happy and content, welcoming and friendly Singaporeans. Smile and the world smiles with you. I would like the world to think of Singapore as a people who can stop to smell the roses.

What do you think?



Tags: ,

 
Total comments: 15
TANZZZZZ
February 18, 2009 Wednesday

Dear Mei Ling,
What a profound question that you have asked! And the timing of asking is impeccable. This cannot come at a better time when tourism numbers are falling and Singaporeans are asking what's going to happen to our society.

A city's message is perhaps a manifestation of the soul of a city which is constantly evolving as the city strives to make itself relevant to the ever changing world.

What does Singapore say to tourists? I once asked a tourist, who stopped me along Shenton Way to ask for directions, what he thinks of Singapore. He started looking around and remarked, "Its just like New York, busy and filled with skyscapers." I then realised that if this is true, then this maybe the death knell for tourism in Singapore. So what is the message that Singapore sends out to tourists?

On the other side of the coin, what message does Singapore says to its citizens? Notice I used the word citizens to distinguish the transient PR population who has no stakeholding in the future of Singapore. In this case I would see Singapore as a community, a society. Let's look around Singapore today (like that american tourist I encountered) and what do we see?
1. Our old folks trying to eke out a living as toilet and food court cleaners.
2. Sending our parents to old folks homes in Singapore, JB and maybe in Batam too!
3. Living in a constant state of self censorship for fear of offending people in authority
4. Being well schooled but uneducated in our history, culture and life & social skills.
5. Able to speak (and write) in multiple languages but unable to think well in any one language.
6. Becoming a nation of whiners and complainers instead of doers and achievers.
7. Following rules and laws to the letter instead promoting the value of fairness and justice
So what message does Singapore speak to its citizens?

I will not be surprised that you (and some of your readers) will disagree with my opinions and even my observations , for they are but a reflection of what Singapore is speaking to me.

So What does Singapore Say?? What an appropriate question.

comment 2659 | Offensive? Report this comment
RLSK
February 18, 2009 Wednesday

Mei Ling. Whats so bizarre about your relatives asking when is your turn to get married. In Chinese culture this is perfectly alright. You are Chinese aren't you. Born and bred in S'pore right? After just two years in a western country and you find our culture unpalatable. Don't forget where you and your ancestors come from

And this car, condo, credit card country club stuff is so yesterday just what are you trying to drive at. Citiens here are bumpkins? Credit card?? C'mon almost every working adult here has one. trying to insult us?

You remind me of your colleague Sim Chi Yin who in my opinion, from the way she writes, dosen't appear to feel comfortable in her own skin.

Please...take a mirror and look at yourself.



comment 2653 | Offensive? Report this comment
pimpmaster
February 16, 2009 Monday

To Livonia>

We all have to admit there is a problem. A problem will not be solved until we acknowledge it exists.

I'm sure some Singaporeans work hard. But unfortunately, for the rest of us, it's not hard enough considering that we are now in a globalized world. There was never a decline in the quality of the Singaporean workforce. The rest of the world just got better, we lost of our competitiveness, and we conveniently blame our government.

The only foreigners who work in Singapore are those who got their university degrees from their countries. It is not their fault that many of the foreign students that we sponsor left Singapore and moved on to greener pastures.

The statistics are available at the Ministry of Manpower and Ministry of Education.

comment 2634 | Offensive? Report this comment
sharlynrj
February 16, 2009 Monday

You really really wanna know.
What it sends out is that we are so busy, busy, busy and so selfish doing our thing, whatever it is; that when it comes to it.....we are now asked to think about sending our elderly to some hell-hole nursing home in JB.....because....surprise...we it's too expensive here and we cannot afford to honour the promise of affordable healthcare to our senior citizens, the very people that built this beautiful country.

comment 2628 | Offensive? Report this comment
Livonia
February 08, 2009 Sunday

"70% of our population are too complacent with just poly diplomas."

Pray tell, pimpmaster, where did you get that figure from? The Dept of Statistics? Not sure if you claimed to be what you are, a NATIVE Singaporean. But I do know the facts that Singaporeans are perpetually signing up for foreign universities degree programmes. Especially MBAs.

If you want to bluff, at least know how to bluff.

Foreigners PAYING their way for their DEGREES? Another lie. Since when they paid with their blood and sweat especially those in NUS and NTU?

IF you want to study in foreign Universities, surely you would pay with YOUR blood and sweat. Unless you are sponsored by a SUGAR MUMMY.

Talk about talking through the derierre.

comment 2534 | Offensive? Report this comment

Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply:

(1) Stay on topic;
(2) No abuse, please;
(3) No personal attacks;
(4) No curse words;
(5) Don't SCREAM in ALL CAPS!

To encourage a meaningful and pleasant dialogue, comments may be deleted. We look forward to your participation!

Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement | Terms & Conditions