|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Andy Chen
Deputy Editor, Life! and Lifestyle
Realism? In a melodrama? Get real!
January 06, 2009 Tuesday, 03:11 PM
Andy Chen discusses whether Little Nyonya's ending was true to life.
ROUGHLY one in three Singaporeans tuned in to the finale of the MediaCorp Channel 8 drama serial, Little Nyonya. But not too many were happy with the ending. Jeanette Aw's title character, Yueniang, did not enjoy a happily-ever-after ending with her prince charming, Chen Xi, played by Qi Yu Wu. Instead, the Little Nyonya of Japanese and Chinese Peranakan descent abandons the love of her life, leaving him to think she died in a fire. Then she goes off to marry a British lawyer, probably in hopes of starting a United Colours of Benetton/United Nations DNA strand in her family gene pool.
Maybe she just preferred fusion food? Apparently, the powers-that-be at Channel 8 thought it was a good ending. "Realistic" is how they described it. And they aren't necessarily wrong either. In life, you don't always get what you want, and when you do a good deed like help your step-cousin escape from an arranged marriage, you could well end up raped, abused, impregnated, tortured and left for dead by a monster of a husband. That kind of things MUST happen all the time back in the old days. And THAT must surely be realistic. I don't know what kind of life experiences the scriptwriters and drama producers have had (and I don't want to be presumptuous, in case some of them have had relatives who have been raped, abused, impregnated, tortured, forced to eat bugs, worms and rats, and then left for dead). But realism flew the coop the moment an ageing matriarch played by Lin Meijiao could throw a 20-something Yueniang taller than herself into the sea from a ship as effortlessly munching an ang ku kueh. I mean, come on, even Pierre Png has to exert more energy coping his Chinese lines. Even more "realistically", Yueniang survives, as does her young daughter who is also tossed into the ocean like last season's sarong kebaya. The quest for realism must also be the reason Yueniang, always looking fetching in her thin, sheer Peranakan blouses, could remain a virgin for years, despite running around with a bunch of uneducated thugs. Must be something in the Peranakan food she feeds them that dampens their libido. I could go on, but you get the point (even if the drama producers didn't). This. Is. A. Melodrama. It is why housewives and closet aunties tune in to watch this instead of following developments in the Gaza Strip on CNN. Give 'em either a romantic walk into the sunset or have EVERYONE go up in flames. As the Chinese idiom goes: Tong gui yu jin. Romance or doom! None of that half-assed "realistic" rubbish. How do YOU think Little Nonya should have ended? Leave your comments here and take our poll! Tags: entertainment
Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||
![]() |
|
|
|
Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or
FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co.
Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement
| Terms & Conditions
|
i feel yueniang is a kind of person who is loyal and honest.although i do not like the ending,as i wanted to see happy ending,i can understand why the director choose this as a ending.yueniang believes that her love ending will not be as happy as what she wants to be because she knew that her mother and ma ma both did not have a happy ending.she believe that her huang family will not let her to be with cheng xi.forget i ba.not all love stories have happy endings.
I agree with the main point of this article. The Little Nyonya is the same show that glorified the epic melodramatic love story of Juxiang and Yousuke in the first 8 episodes of the drama. The script lauded Juxiang for taking her destiny into her own hands, running away from her arranged marriage with Charlie Zhang, finding her one true love (Yousuke), and marrying him without parental consent. Although Juxiang and Yousuke died young, the show always beautified their till-death-do-us-part romance. It's really incongruous of the producers and scriprwriters to give us a "realistic" ending when they set the tone of the show with such a "hong1 hong1 lie4 lie4" love story.
Also, while arranged marriages are indeed a reality of the past, the show always portrayed them in a negative light. The arranged/forced marriages of Jincheng & Xiufeng, Chen Sheng & Meiyu, Liu Yidao & Yueniang, Chen Xi & Zhenzhu, and Robert Zhang & Yuzhu, are all failures in various ways. Jincheng cheated on Xiufeng with her sister; Chen Sheng and Meiyu's marriage was completely loveless and left them both chronically unhappy; Yueniang refused to consummate her marriage with Liu Yidao and even threatened to burn herself, eventually dissolving the marriage altogether; Chen Xi + Zhenzhu was a failure from the get-go and ended with Zhenzhu eloping with another man; Yuzhu tried to kill Robert on her wedding night and Robert subsequently tortured her into insanity. Therefore I find it contradictory of the show's finale to tell us that the best thing for Chen Xi is to stay in his forced marriage with Zhenzhu.
And I don't buy scriptwriter Mr Ang Eng Tee's comments that he wanted Chen Xi and Yueniang to end up together but the storylines and characters had developed in a way that didn't allow him to. Since Zhenzhu eventually eloped in his script, Chen Xi became single again. Mr Ang could have chosen to have Chen Xi and Yueniang get together at this point, but he chose not to.
when the writer of this blog does not watch the serial thoroughly, it is inevitable to display negative comments...I would think this is the best mediacorp production ever made as it touches on culture of Peranakan as well as depicting a history of such co-currences in the past, ie arranged marriage.
nyOnya is real, but "little nyanya" the drama is just another drama series. let's be real with the real and watch the drama with apich of salt. Escapism is helpful in times like present crisis to imagine again the love story .
Thanks for the blogger's off and none realitic comments. happy watching the make-believe, but let's live in reality too.
wow ! seems like the comments to this blog about Little Nyonya is soon going to exceed the 34-episodes ! haha... 5 more, 5 more ! and I just wanted to add... I think whoever that felt the pinch from all these critics about the ending episodes, must have panicked ! and whoever that came up with the idea of that 5 minutes "thank you" note on last Sunday was just adding oil to the fire ! it is just laughable !
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >