|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Wong Mei Ling
Journalist, Foreign Desk
China in transition
October 07, 2008 Tuesday, 11:54 AM
Wong Mei Ling reflects on China's social capital.
In Beijing FRENCH sociologist Pierre Bourdieu argued that there are three kinds of capital in any given society: economic, social and cultural. An individual, he said, can successfully accumulate economic capital, but that does not automatically ensure his acceptance into the elite circles, unless he also possesses social and cultural capital. I was reminded of Bourdieu's theory yesterday as I set foot in China for the first time. China is progressing at a fast pace within a very short time as is evident from the extraordinary display of the accumulation of economic capital. Here is a country seeking to earn its rightful place in the elite circle of the international arena. But China remains outside of the world's elite powers and we have seen many recent symbolic events designed to acquire social capital. The sheer superiority of creativity and discipline that went into the organisation of the just-concluded Olympic Games stunned the world. And if that was not enough to impress, it was followed shortly later by China's third manned space mission. Also, Chinese movies are now making waves on the international screen, with bigger budgets and Hollywood collaborations, effectively marketing Chinese history and culture as rich, exotic and romantic. But my first impressions at the Beijing international airport yesterday left me wondering if this Asian giant has quite a lot of catching up to do on the cultural capital front. The modern facade of the airport and the multitude of fashionably clad Chinese were a sharp contrast to the decibel levels emanating from that place. People were screaming at each other or barking into their phones, quite a disjunct from the systematic and orderly fashion of their surroundings. The hallway was packed with people and crossing it was more difficult than trying to cross the busy Orchard Road during peak hours (at least Orchard Road has speed limits and traffic lights to give pedestrians occassional respite). I was almost bowled over the a speeding trolley overloaded with luggage about thrice my size, and my attempts to get into the sky train were met with uncompassionate pushing, shoving and trampling by all those trying to get into the compartment. But outside the airport, the meticulously manicured landscape with little flowering plants carefully arranged along the highway, captured my sensibilities, making me forget my earlier ordeal. The country is truly speeding along the highway of economic capital, but those of us who have a head start in a developed country may look at it and think they lack social or cultural capital. Nevertheless, knowing China, it will be a relentless chase but the Chinese will surely catch up with all the capitals of the world. Tags: china, economy
Your comments are welcome. The following rules apply: |
|
|
Other blogs by Wong Mei Ling
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||
![]() |
|
|
|
Best viewed at 1152x864 resolution with IE 6.0 or
FireFox 2.0 and above Copyright © 2007 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co.
Regn No. 198402868E | Privacy Statement
| Terms & Conditions
|
To Maria Loi:
I just wonder during their ancient historic period if they were gracious?
-- Please ask your parents or great parents or great great parents, if they were gracious.
I don’t understand how they got into Canada?
-- How did you get into Canada? Because You behave graciously? Is this gracious behavior or attitude you possess towards the Chinese?
Thanks Mei Ling,
Its been a while,
I ditto the fact that we Singaporeans were similar in the not too distant past with all those "get better" campaigns, broken Mcdonalds windows for Hello Kitties, and all those "forgettable" moments of our Singaporean ugliness that rued the headlines of certain papers in the world and locally
But at the end of the day, it really boils down to how we can make up for it. Every modernized and developed nation have its teething problems.
Cheerios
Marcus Loke Weng Tuck
Thank you for all your great comments. Su Yin I totally agree with you that it is nice to have diversity. I myself lament the Singapore-style malls I saw sprouting in various cities in the region. I also do agree that it is important to preserve the free spirit of a place and its people which ever so often gets lost in the process of 'development'.
Maria, thank you for your lovely reply too. I've been to British Columbia couple of times. It is a gorgeous place!
It's also interesting that Stephen mentioned that the Chinese government's used ads and banners to educate the public on basic etiquette. It's kind of like Singapore and it's courtesy campaign, smile campaign and 'clean and green Singapore' years back.
We were not so different not so long ago really!
Cheers, Mei Ling
I guess it speaks quite alot about China moving into a new era with all the fantastic infrastruture but lack of what is in it.
The first time i step into China, Shanghai '03.. i remembered that i could not even get into the correct queue to buy a nice Macdonald's burger or a meal at KFC, the simple reason is that the queue is parallel to the counter and people are just squeezing in just to get their meal... what about me? Just walk out and find another restaurant..
5 years down the road now, things have changed quite alot, the queue is better now and quite alot of the younger generations are more cultured and a nice queue is formed.. however there are still some bad hats around.
Though i fully agree about the rowdiness and the intensified decibels ringing through your ears, sometimes you can even hear their "secrets" just sitting a few tables away.
Oh! queues are also being formed now at certain subways stations before they get into the train(just remembering the old days where it looks like a sardine outside the cabin). However, when the door of the cabin opens..."I will win the battle of the Seat".
The chinese governement has actually placed quite alot of adv..banners to educate the people, it is improving but the hardware gets faster than the software part.
Cheers.. Stephen
I lived in China for a year and I agree the software has not caught up with the hardware. But I don't see it as necessarily a bad thing. Why should all cities be alike? I wouldn't want to fly all the way to Beijing just to find another Singapore. In fact, I was rather disturbed by the number of Singapore malls sprouting all over Beijing. While I'm glad Singapore developers are doing well in China, for every mall that is built in the model of Singapore, a piece of the China/Beijing "character" disappears. I love China at its dirtiest, most unhygenic and disorganised. Illegal hawkers crowding the streets displaying their pirated wares, the rich smells of roasting lamb-sticks, sausages, wings and jian bing from temporary street stalls, farmers from nearby villages selling their mud-encrusted vegetables on wooden wagons drawn by mules, crazy cyclists weaving in and out of grid-locked traffic oblivious to the noise and dirt. This to me is the real Beijing and one that will sadly disappear when modernisation creeps in.
1 2 >